• Welcome to DOSBODS

    Please consider creating a free account to be able to access all the features of the DOSBODS community. It only takes 20 seconds!

Sign in to follow this  
One percent

Engine recommendations

Recommended Posts

I'm looking to tap the expertise of the dosbods massive here.

as posted on other threads, we tend to purchase a car nearly new and run it into the ground. Well the rover 75, whilst the engine is still good is suffering from bits breaking and failing. Stupid things like door actuators.

So, we are in the market for a new to us car.  One year old.  Very mixed use.  Trolling round London, m25 and trips to god's own.  

We also have had the diesel selling scandal (the rover has a pre particle filter engine), the rise in alternative fuels.  So, do we go for a petrol (my choice), a Toyota hybrid (mr 1percent's choice) or a new diesel?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm pretty happy with the Diesel Mokka. Feels like a big car and returns about 55 mpg on average.

Never made the 75 mpg claimed by Vauxhall...no surprise there.

And I don't like the idea of driving around with a tank full of explosive petrol.  Diesel doesn't burst into flames when some drunken knob drives into you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Be wary of the new diesel, too much tech to run around London, think clogged particulate filters etc. Plus Diesel is the new Evil for politicians to whip.

I would stick to a petrol especially if your mileage is low,  most are much more efficient than 10 years ago and the engines are still simple.

Petrol is a good holding pattern until things settle down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, One percent said:

I'm looking to tap the expertise of the dosbods massive here.

as posted on other threads, we tend to purchase a car nearly new and run it into the ground. Well the rover 75, whilst the engine is still good is suffering from bits breaking and failing. Stupid things like door actuators.

So, we are in the market for a new to us car.  One year old.  Very mixed use.  Trolling round London, m25 and trips to god's own.  

We also have had the diesel selling scandal (the rover has a pre particle filter engine), the rise in alternative fuels.  So, do we go for a petrol (my choice), a Toyota hybrid (mr 1percent's choice) or a new diesel?

Toyota hybrids can do massive mileages without failure. It'll be better round town than the other options, and less good on the motorway. My advice would be to get a slightly older one than usual as in 3-5 years the technology game-changers will be here.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, swissy_fit said:

Toyota hybrids can do massive mileages without failure. It'll be better round town than the other options, and less good on the motorway. My advice would be to get a slightly older one than usual as in 3-5 years the technology game-changers will be here.

 

Thanks swissy.  All the minicabs in London seem to have gone over the the Prius?, one of the Toyota hybrids, so I would guess they are reliable and efficient round town.  When you say not good on a motorway, what do you mean?  Is it economy or distance ?  

Maybe a noddy question but how do you see engine technology changing in five years?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We just got a Suzuki Ignis and it's fab. We have the 2WD and are getting around 55mpg, there's 4WD "mild" hybrid that apparently returns more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Wahoo said:

I'm pretty happy with the Diesel Mokka. Feels like a big car and returns about 55 mpg on average.

Never made the 75 mpg claimed by Vauxhall...no surprise there.

And I don't like the idea of driving around with a tank full of explosive petrol.  Diesel doesn't burst into flames when some drunken knob drives into you.

Funny wahoo, I've never had my petrol tank explode on me. xD  on a serious note, I guess it is a possibility and some I knew years ago had a low slung Toyota that had a tendency to explode on crashing. Sadly it did and she didn't make it. I hope that things have been improved since then.

a mate has the Mokka, not sure of the engine but I was impressed. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Petrol for me.

I bought my first Diesel a couple of months back, and I'm currently learning the hard way.

Discovered clutch slipping on the drive home.  Got that sorted (without having to do the DMF), then a few weeks later the DPF light came on and that needed replacing.

If you're buying 1 year old, you'll be ok though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, swissy_fit said:

Whatever qualities it may have (and it does, to be fair), it's still a filthy stinking diesel. :P

Aye, but unlike the VW never smell it, one hell of an engine in that thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I suspect that diesels will be taxed out of London soon. I'd go petrol. I test drove a Toyota Prius a couple of years ago - hated it, like driving a milk float. I think they are also more complicated with the additional electrics to allow the car to switch power sources, does that mean you are limited to who services it - I'm a firm believer in not using a main dealer once out of warranty and if you run a car for years that difference in servicing costs can run up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, sisyphal said:

Petrol for me.

I bought my first Diesel a couple of months back, and I'm currently learning the hard way.

Discovered clutch slipping on the drive home.  Got that sorted (without having to do the DMF), then a few weeks later the DPF light came on and that needed replacing.

If you're buying 1 year old, you'll be ok though.

What make?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Chewing Grass said:

Be wary of the new diesel, too much tech to run around London, think clogged particulate filters etc. Plus Diesel is the new Evil for politicians to whip.

I would stick to a petrol especially if your mileage is low,  most are much more efficient than 10 years ago and the engines are still simple.

Petrol is a good holding pattern until things settle down.

Thanks chewy, my view but mr 1percent is not convinced. He has a tendency to believe what the msm tell him.  Yes I know, he is on the reeducation programme 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Dipsy said:

I suspect that diesels will be taxed out of London soon. I'd go petrol. I test drove a Toyota Prius a couple of years ago - hated it, like driving a milk float. I think they are also more complicated with the additional electrics to allow the car to switch power sources, does that mean you are limited to who services it - I'm a firm believer in not using a main dealer once out of warranty and if you run a car for years that difference in servicing costs can run up.

That's the common problem with hybrids the drivetrain does not respond in the same way - that and CVT only many of them. Test driving in various road conditions definitely needed before going hybrid route.

Edited by onlyme

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, onlyme said:

Yaris 1.4D bomb proof, a few thou off 180K. Problem will be the new rules for diesel in town centres if they come through.

This is the issue too.  The 75 is going to be banned from London by khan (my dad was a bus driver) in the next couple of years 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, sisyphal said:

Petrol for me.

I bought my first Diesel a couple of months back, and I'm currently learning the hard way.

Discovered clutch slipping on the drive home.  Got that sorted (without having to do the DMF), then a few weeks later the DPF light came on and that needed replacing.

If you're buying 1 year old, you'll be ok though.

The rover 75 engine is bomb proof. Sadly the new ones (are they called common rail?) have a poor rep.  Coupled with the particulate and I don't think I would want one

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Dipsy said:

I suspect that diesels will be taxed out of London soon. I'd go petrol. I test drove a Toyota Prius a couple of years ago - hated it, like driving a milk float. I think they are also more complicated with the additional electrics to allow the car to switch power sources, does that mean you are limited to who services it - I'm a firm believer in not using a main dealer once out of warranty and if you run a car for years that difference in servicing costs can run up.

Good points dipsy. The Prius is favoured by mini cab drivers so I've been in a few.  Milk floats as you say and they seem to creak. Maybe it is just that there is no engine noise to mask noise. Toyota do the hybrid almost across the range now and some of them look quite nicely styled

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, One percent said:

Thanks swissy.  All the minicabs in London seem to have gone over the the Prius?, one of the Toyota hybrids, so I would guess they are reliable and efficient round town.  When you say not good on a motorway, what do you mean?  Is it economy or distance ?  

Maybe a noddy question but how do you see engine technology changing in five years?

I like the Prius after 2009, and the 2016 one is better. Very smooth, quiet and economical round town. On the motorway, they are ok cruising but accelerating at speed streches the drive train a bit. Creaky old taxis have probably done 400k miles..... 

I'm expecting multiple plug-in hybrids with 60 mile + electric range (and thus requiring petrol only on long runs) and mainstream battery cars with <400 miles real range in the next 3-5 years. Eventually the ICE-only  cars will be taxed/phased out.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, onlyme said:

What make?

A Honda Accord, believe it or not.

09 Reg, 60K on the clock.  Ostensibly well looked after with Full Service History and right type of previous owner, but it's been nothing but trouble so far.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, One percent said:

Very nice Dave but what about the engine?  

I think it was 1.4 105 brake.  I have a Seat Leon Cupra 1st gen, which is double that!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Dave Bloke
      Anyone running E85 in their car? There seem to be quite a few people who use this in their recent (non E85) engines with no issues. It is less than half the price of Lead Free 95.
    • By swiss_democracy_for_all
      Only called the thread this because from memory Frank has recent diesel carss and Pinny drives old petrols. Which is what get compared here.....
      New diesels get a pasting as well.
      http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-41640746
    • By The Masked Tulip
      Long post... one for the bike folks...
      The rear rim on my main bike wore out last week. The front wheel looks as if it might go before long. I am now riding it with the rear V-brakes undone and just braking on the front  brakes. It is a Globe 700c ladies bike - I bought it for a gf around 2007 but we split up a couple of months later or so I got it back from her.
      The saddle is also knackered with a growing hole in the right side.
      It sat in the shed for a few years whilst I was unwell and then I began using it as a means of improving my health. I have now basically used it every day for about 7 years. I have a Marin full suspension but I rarely use that nowadays as I do mostly road and country tracks, slight off-road but nothing heavy off-road. I really like this ladies bike - it rides well and the fact that there is no horizontal bar endangering my man-bits has been a joy. I have really thrashed it around as a result. Much easier to get on and off as well.
      Anyhow, to the point of this thread.
      I am contemplating whether I replace the rear wheel on the bike or I go and buy a new one.
      I got some quotes from various bike places and they seem to be wanting to sell me a wheel in the £60 to £75 range and then charging me about £50 to do the work. So, about £120 for the wheel and job. As I said, I also need a new saddle and have price the one I fancy at about £40 - £50.
      I was looking last night for buying a cheap wheel on ebay - about £40 - and buying the tools required to do it myself. The tools would be about another £35. My reluctance on this is whether I am able to actually remove the cassette - could it be jammed - after buying the parts and tools required. Not done this kind of bike maintenance before.
      It is an odd thing. I have had so much pleasure from this bike that I am reluctant to let it go. But I am also concerned about replacing parts only for other expensive parts to go.
      So I have been looking at the possibility of a new bike for a few weeks now. (F*ck, there are twats working in bike shops - they seem to want to direct you to the biike that is best for them and not you.).
      I have been looking at the Giant range of bikes - the Roam hybrids with front suspension on the front. Nice bikes, a bit pricey and seem a bit heavy. We have lots of cycle routes in Swansea but they involve lots of moving from road to pavement and back again with little 1 or 2 inch high curbs - I am thinking the front suspension would be the way to go to make a nicer ride. Also, it would be good for country roads, tracks, etc. Price £400 to £600.
      Bizarrely, the sizes stated by the manufacturer for my height and leg size just feels too large - perhaps because I have been riding the ladies bike for so long. Certainly, the sloping horizontal bar on the male bikes seem dangerously close to the crown jewels.
      But I find myself again and again looking at the Giant (Liv) ladies bike model that is basically similar to the one I am riding now - the Liv Alight. Nothing special in terms of components but just a fun looking bike, albeit without any suspension, and a more reasonable price range of £350 to £500.
      I am also probably going to get a pannier for whatever bike I buy as I do all my shopping on my bike and I am making too many shopping trips due to lack of space in a ruck-sack.
      I really would prefer to wait until Sept sales to buy and perhaps get 25% off the above price - assuming my current bike lasts that long. I could always use my mountain-bike if it does pack in.
      Just to add. I have looked at electric bikes but they are still prohibitive IMPO. I am also wondering whether the hybrid suspension - i.e. something like the Giant Roam - would suffice as one bike or whether, longer-term, I buy a basic 'shopping bike' like the bove-mentioned Liv Alight and then, maybe later on, buy some kind of racing or cyclecross bike for a bit more fun. It is a complicated thing buying bikes these days.
      So, anyway, just putting it out there - do I attempt the repair or do I go for the new bike? Thoughts welcome.
       
       
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.